So I was flipping through the channels last night and I caught a few minutes of JAG. Cheezy Courtroom drama. yay. But this episode was actually kind of interesting. The story revolved around a Marine Recon unit that was inserted right next to a brigade of the Republican Guard. In order to escape, they had to kill a goat herder who, being right next to their location, was sure to alert the Iraqis. The Sergeant order to kill the shepard (with a K-Bar), froze upon sight of the target and did not kill him. The shepard then went and alerted the Iraqis, thereby causing the Recon unit to abort their mission and extract.
The one problem, the shepard was a 10 year old boy.
Now, some would say that it is always wrong to kill a 10 year old (I hope everyone would actually). The problem lies when the child is an active agent for an enemy force. Ever since Vietnam we have been fighting people who do not wear a uniform, yet they are still part of an enemy force that is seeking to do us harm.
Through this justification, as strange as it may seem, it is ethically correct to kill the 10 year old boy. The only reason it is correct is because he was acting as a part of the Iraqi Republican Guard by alerting them to the presence of the Marines. He could have kept his non-combatant role (and be immune to assault) simply by ignoring the Marines and going about his way. In general, a Marine has no more right to kill a non-combatant civilian than he does to kill his fellow Marines. However, when those civilians choose the support an enemy force, there is no other option but to terminate them.
Now that's some cold shit. And it got me thinking. Could I do that? Not that I actually expect to hear a concrete answer from my psyche, but I could I could stare into the eyes of a small child and stab it to death with a knife. Thinking about it casuses it to become this very visual movie in my head. I don't believe that I have a problem killing adults. That sounds psycho I know, but it's not that I
want to kill them, it that killing them must be done. But a child? No matter what ethics says, that's always a tough call and possibly an imppossible one.